Tonight I relived Jamie's baby days as I sat on the couch in the dark, long past his bedtime, and nursed him into a deep, deep slumber by the light of the almost mute tv. It was either that or spend another night frustrated and pissed off and guilty for being pissed at my poor, sweet, hurting baby. I've been frustrated enough that MD has expressed some concern the following day, and rightly so.
Whenever I lose sight of my original parenting philosophy - do what works now, and sort it out later - it comes back and bites me in the ass. And, when I lose faith in my own methods, it never ends well. When Jamie's tantruming, MD's method is to gently talk him through it. He just talks. And talks, and talks, about everything and nothing, until Jamie finally settles down. It's really awesome and from time to time I feel guilty for my own response, which is to silently sit until the storm passes. The problem is, if I start talking, I get frustrated when Jamie doesn't respond the way I want him to, which is calm the hell down. No matter that he's freaking two. The gentle talking gives way to pleading, which gives way to impatience, which finally yields to anger. So the past couple of nights I've sat silently, offering comfort from time to time, until he's ready to accept it. I've nursed when neccessary, putting aside my impatience with nursing for the time being, and finally, tonight when it was obvious that he wasn't going to fall deeply asleep until the next dose of tylenol 3 kicked in and I couldn't stop thinking about last night's episode of the Amazing Race that was paused on the dvr, I took him downstairs and walked him around in the darkened family room where the light and sound of the fish tank (Dur? Dite dere!) finally calmed him to the point that it only took about 10 minutes of nursing for him to finally fall into a fitful sleep in my arms. An episode of the Amazing Race and the last half of What Not to Wear later, I was able to put him back into his own bed, at least as long as it's taken me to finish my dinner and get ready for bed so that if he does wake again soon, I can just climb into bed with him for the night.
I have two sides to my personality that are battling with each other during situations like these. The part of me that craves order and routine versus the part that hates rules and flies by the seat of her pants. Flipping back and forth while trying to maintain a consistent set of boundaries and "rules" (our rules are so general it's ridiculous - mostly about not hurting anyone or anything living and manners) wears on me. But really, how many more times will I have to snuggle him by the glow of the tv? How many more opportunities will I have to study his face as he sleeps, still angelic, with the tiniest bit of babyhood still present? Living in the moment is just as important as working toward the future person he'll be and the two don't have to be at odds with one another.

Well, it took us all weekend to shop for and buy the mattress and a dresser to replace the changing table (and to put the dresser together, but that's another story) so last night was the first night in the new bed. And of course, either the damn molars or another ear infection had him waking, screaming, almost hourly. But I did get to test my theory that I could just sleep next to him on a bad night! And he went down just fine, which, I have to tell you, your advice about betime not being stressful is right on. It's always been my philosphy as well, and that's why we've coslept off and on, because I just don't have the patience or the energy to mess around. If it's bedtime, I want the kid asleep and in bed so I can move on with the evening. I've been feeling an enormous sense of relief about not having to deal with the crib at bedtime, and I've actually been putting him down in our bed from the start since the crib-climbing incident and he's been sleeping straight through until 5 or so.
"Our daughter has never been the type who wants to get up and play at night."
That's Jamie exactly, which is why I've dealt with his nightwakings the way I have. Even our pediatrician, who raisesd an eyebrow when at his 15 month checkup found out he was waking again at night, dismissed it when I told her they were brief, less than a minute or so, wakings.
Even if we continue to cosleep off and on, I think, Moxie, you're exactly right about the power struggle. This takes the power issue out of the equation, which means I'm not second-guessing myself anymore and can respond to the situation at hand, rather than wondering how my respons is going to impact things down the road.